The Signpost
Single-page Edition
WP:POST/1
24 February 2016

Special report
WMF in limbo as decision on Tretikov nears
Op-ed
Backward the Foundation
Traffic report
Of Dead Pools and Dead Judges
Blog
Wiki Loves Africa brings the continent’s fashion to the world
Arbitration report
Arbitration motion regarding CheckUser & Oversight inactivity
Featured content
This week's featured content
Technology report
Tech news in brief
 

2016-02-24

[UPDATED] WMF in limbo as decision on Tretikov nears


During a papal conclave to choose a new Pope, white smoke from the Sistine Chapel indicates a decision has been made. [updated]


After a series of closed-door meetings this week by the Wikimedia Foundation's Board of Trustees, WMF staffers widely believe that the Board is deciding the fate of executive director Lila Tretikov.

Tretikov's tumultuous tenure has seen a number of dramatic events in recent months, including the dismissal of community-selected Board of Trustees member James Heilman (Doc James); the appointment of trustee Arnnon Geshuri, and his resignation following a community outcry; and the controversy around a Knight Foundation grant for a project called "Knowledge Engine", which at one point may have been intended to be a competitor with Google.

While at least the first two issues could be attributed to the Board's political mistakes, WMF staffers widely attribute a series of high-profile employee departures from the WMF to issues with Tretikov's leadership. A timeline of events at the WMF was recently created by GorillaWarfare, illustrating many instances of staff turmoil, including a number of incidents that were not publicly known outside WMF circles.

Staff concerns about Tretikov came to a head at a remarkable all-staff meeting last November 9, details of which are only now becoming public. An apologetic Tretikov, flanked by Jimmy Wales and Board chair Patricio Lorente, confronted the assembled WMF staffers and pledged to improve communication and leadership. Tretikov told them, in part,

First of all, I owe you all an apology, for not seeing this earlier, and it started percolating few weeks ago when some people started telling me some of the problems they were seeing. So, I'm really, really sorry for anything that I've said or done that have made you feel devalued in any respect, or disrespected or not listened to. It was not at all my intent. I deeply believe that, and I think I've said that, or somehow I'm failing to communicate it.

A dramatic question and answer session followed, but many WMF employees seemed bewildered by what resembled a moment of truth, and were unsure about the circumstances that had prompted it. One staffer later termed it a "show trial" of Tretikov, while others vented about perceived failures of leadership during the meeting itself. One prominent staffer, Asaf Bartov (Asaf (WMF)), directly accused Tretikov of lying about the Knowledge Engine, which has been a particular flashpoint in conflicts between Tretikov and WMF staff.

Many staffers had little information about the project, despite the fact that the WMF was asking for millions of dollars from the Knight Foundation to implement it. Heilman told the Signpost that he and fellow Board member Dariusz Jemielniak had to fight a reluctant Tretikov and other Board members to receive key documents about the Knowledge Engine. Regarding this accusation leveled at Tretikov, Bartov later wrote on Facebook:

It was only after staff (outside the Discovery team, *who were also in the dark* regarding the grant and what was written in it) began asking persistent questions on the staff-wide mailing list about the mysterious and undefined "Knowledge Engine" that Lila shared any information at all.

The Discovery team is tasked with implementing the Knowledge Engine, yet according to the minutes of last week's Discovery meeting, which contained some candid discussion, some team members appear to have learned key details about the project from a Signpost report.

The issue of Tretikov's management and leadership style was intended to be addressed by the appointment of Steve Scheier as a management coach in November. Scheier worked at Apple in the 1980s with Guy Kawasaki, a member of the Board of Trustees who has been widely seen as sympathetic to Tretikov. Kawasaki provided a blurb for Scheier's 2015 book Do More Good. Better. Using the Power of Decision Clarity® to Mobilize the Talent of your Nonprofit Team, stating "This book removed the scales from my eyes and taught me that nonprofits are a different beast—in distribution of power, relationships with constituencies, and employee recruitment and retention. If you want to optimize the leadership of a nonprofit, this is the hands-on guide to help you succeed."

Guy Kawasaki, trustee, appointed April 13, 2015 – December 31, 2016
Scheier's experience as a management coach seemed ideal to address the situation, but WMF staffers raised questions about what exactly his job was and, later on, whether or not he was still working with Tretikov. In an email to all staffers last week, she wrote that she was still meeting with him and had an upcoming appointment scheduled; a staffer responded by producing an email from Scheier that said he was no longer working for the WMF. Tretikov responded: "Ok I am confused now too". After subsequent communication with Scheier, Tretikov called it a "misunderstanding" between her and Scheier and that he would be helping her work on "strategic organizational goals". These included "clarifying the nature of our organization going forward", a phrase that several staffers questioned.

In earlier months, staff voiced fears of retaliation and described a "culture of fear" at the WMF, such as a February 1 comment to Tretikov by Community Tech developer Frances Hocutt: "I hear my colleagues' concerns and see some of them being censured for speaking in ways that I have found sharply critical but still fundamentally honest and civil, and I worry that someday I will be the one who is suddenly found to have stepped over lines which were previously invisible or unspoken."

The depth of these problems was revealed in an anonymous staff survey held in late November. As the Signpost revealed, the survey indicated that trust levels were abysmally low. Just 10% of staff indicated that they had confidence in the WMF's senior leadership, a number widely interpreted as a direct reflection on Tretikov. An even lower 7% of staffers indicated that those senior leaders "keep people informed about what is happening."

In recent weeks, staffers have spoken out more directly and brazenly, responding to Tretikov and even contradicting her directly both in public and private. They appear to have been galvanized by a number of recent events, most notably the resignations of Luis Villa, senior director of Community Engagement, and Siko Bouterse, director of Community Resources—the most recent in a long line of staff departures and medical leaves from the WMF over the past two years, triggering particularly strong responses.

A February 18 message from Ido Ivri also prompted a number of frank responses from current and former WMF employees and community members. Ivri, a board member of Wikimedia Israel, wrote:

I’m concerned because it’s evident that the Foundation is undergoing a deep, strategic change. But this change is not accompanied by the required transparency, honesty and accountability required by the Foundation in order to truly transform in a way that's beneficial for the organization and its community.

While WMF staffers are convinced that Tretikov's departure is imminent, staff resignations have continued amid concerns about the long-term future of the Foundation and the ability of the Board to address these issues. The latest departure, announced Tuesday, is that of Research Analyst Oliver Keyes (Ironholds). Although he used much sterner language in an internal email seen by the Signpost, Keyes publicly stated that "While I appreciate that the Board of Trustees may take steps to rectify the situation, I have no confidence in their ability to effectively do so given their failure to solve for the problem until it became a publicity issue as well as a staff complaint."

Update: On February 25, Tretikov announced her resignation, effective March 31, 2016. In her resignation statement, Tretikov said, "I will support the process of identifying our new leadership in every way that I can, and offer my assistance to the Board as they conduct their search for my successor. It has been an honor to serve and to contribute to our great movement." The Board of Trustees announced their acceptance of her resignation.

The WMF issued an official statement to The Next Web, which we have reprinted below in full:

On Thursday, February 25, Lila Tretikov announced she will step down from her role as Executive Director of the Wikimedia Foundation.

“I am both inspired by, and proud of, the many great things we have all accomplished at the Foundation over the last two years, most significantly reversing the loss of our editorial community,” Lila wrote in her email to staff and community. “I would like to thank our Board of Trustees and Advisors, our Foundation staff, as well as the many outstanding community members for their support and encouragement on this journey. I remain passionate about the value and potential of open knowledge and Wikimedia to change the world.”

The Wikimedia Foundation Board of Trustees is working to develop a transition plan that will include appointing interim leadership and initiating the search for a new Executive Director. Lila’s last day will be March 31, 2016.

Lila joined as Executive Director in May 2014 to support the maturation of the Wikimedia Foundation and focus the organization on the needs of its community and users. During this time, the organization has made real progress in these areas. The Foundation has improved organizational performance and product development, released new native apps, editor translation and content quality assessment tools. Many talented members of our staff and community contributed to these accomplishments, and we want to recognize their hard work and commitment to our mission.

“These changes are in motion and I move on with confidence that the Foundation can meet new challenges in a changing environment” said Lila, “I remain passionate about the value and potential of open knowledge to change the world and our ability to continue to lead this change.”

Since it started fifteen years ago, Wikipedia has grown into one of the world’s most important knowledge resources, thanks to the efforts of hundreds of thousands of volunteers around the world. The focus of the Wikimedia Foundation has always been to support that community and the Wikimedia projects, and to help make free knowledge available for the world.

“The Wikimedia’s vision is clear: a world in which every single person can share in the sum of all knowledge. Even as we go through changes, our focus remains on this vision,” said Patricio Lorente, Chair of the Wikimedia Foundation Board of Trustees. “The Wikimedia Foundation has strong leadership and a talented staff devoted to this vision and our movement’s core values. They will continue to support the Wikimedia projects and community, and we are confident that we are well positioned to move forward at this time. We thank Lila for her service and wish her the best in her future endeavors.”

Lila will remain engaged with the Wikimedia Foundation to support the transition process.



Reader comments

2016-02-24

Backward the Foundation



Reader comments

2016-02-24

Of dead pools and dead judges

Summary: There was a lot going on this week: the Grammys; the Presidential primaries in Nevada and South Carolina; and the death of Supreme Court justice Antonin Scalia, which provoked an entirely predictable and completely unnecessary political firestorm. But what people wanted to know about more than anything, it seems, is Deadpool; a film which, judging from the box office receipts, they've already seen. Still, that's a lot to take in, and I can't really blame people for seeking an escape.

As prepared by Serendipodous, for the week of February 14–20, 2016, the 10 most popular articles on Wikipedia, as determined from the report of the most viewed pages, were:

Rank Article Class Views Image Notes
1 Deadpool (film) Start-class 2,846,632
The Marvel Comics antihero film starring Ryan Reynolds (pictured) was released on February 12 to a stellar reception. Regarded as a risk by its makers 20th Century Fox, the film has earned nearly $500 million worldwide in just ten days. Reviews are surprisingly strong as well, with the film averaging 84% on Rotten Tomatoes.
2 Antonin Scalia Featured Article 2,131,575
Oh dear. US politics are getting dirty again. The longest-serving Supreme Court Justice in modern history, Scalia held his position for nearly 30 years until his sudden death this week at the age of 79. Despite his rigidly originalist Constitutional stance and conservative views on homosexuality and abortion, he was apparently well-liked even by the more liberal members of the court. Even so, his death leaves the Court in an even 4–4 split between liberals and conservatives, a fact which concerns the Republican-held Senate enough that Majority Leader Mitch McConnell, who famously said his one goal would be to make Barack Obama a one-term president, declared that the Senate would not approve any replacement candidate Obama might put forward. Whether he will follow through with his threat, and whether voters will reward such obstructionism or reject it, remains to be seen.
3 Deadpool C-class 1,735,849
Marvel may have disavowed their X-Men franchise until Fox gives it back to them, but their fourth wall-tickling, chimichanga-chomping, bullet-spraying loony toon obviously remains a potent force, whether they like it or not.
4 Valentine's Day C-Class 1,271,571
The annual greeting-card consumption festival got fewer views than usual this week. Typically (see 2013 and 2014 and 2015), Valentine's Day makes its annual appearance at the top of the chart. Since the 14th fell on the first day of this week's report, it didn't have the benefit of the pre-holiday views in its totals.
5 The Life of Pablo C-Class 1,060,242
The latest album from Kanye West (pictured) was released this week to positive-if-perplexed reviews and some typically unhinged comments from its creator (see #8)
6 Alexander Hamilton Good Article 1,051,465
This Founding Father of the United States, who was shot in a duel by then-Vice President Aaron Burr, is probably best known as the soon-to-be-ex-face of the ten dollar bill. Rather surprisingly, his life became the subject of a hit off-Broadway musical, the theme to which earned a Grammy Award for Best Musical Theater Album this week.
7 Donald Trump B-Class 998,114
In the alien, non-Euclidean geometry of this year's United States presidential election, down apparently means up. It doesn't matter what Donald Trump does; engage in a Twitter war with the Pope, tell a group of veterans that he would deal with Islamic terrorists by having them shot with bullets dipped in pigs' blood, or have "loser.com" redirect to his Wikipedia page, he can't be brought back to Earth. Having secured the Republican New Hampshire primary for on February 9, he went on to win the South Carolina primary by a similar margin, despite pundits predicting that Ted Cruz would benefit from the state's large Evangelical demographic. If he pulls similar numbers on March 1's "Super Tuesday" primaries, expect his nomination to be declared secure.
8 Kanye West Good Article 833,443
It's the Grammys again, and that means it's time for another incoherent spiel from Kanye West. The previous recipient of the dubious honour of having "loser.com" redirect to his Wikipedia page managed to make, if possible, an even more insulting fool of himself this year, this time targeting Album of the Year winner Taylor Swift. After West claimed he wouldn't attend the ceremony if he didn't win said award (he wasn't nominated), Swift made an oblique reference to him in her acceptance speech, and in particular his lyrics to one of the songs on his just-released album: "I feel like me and Taylor might still have sex/Why? I made that bitch famous/Goddamn, I made that bitch famous." This line is presumably a reference to the time he jumped on the stage during her acceptance speech at the VMAs to tell her she didn't deserve to win. After failing to win the award he wasn't nominated for, Kanye went on Twitter to claim he was $53 million in debt and that Mark Zuckerberg should help him out. Some are beginning to wonder if hip hop's insufferable genius may be easing on the "genius" while doubling down on the "insufferable".
9 O. J. Simpson B-Class 934,959
As predicted by yours truly, the former football player, Leslie Nielsen costar and alleged murderer has become a fixture of this list, thanks to the first season of American Crime Story, the true-crime spinoff of American Horror Story, which focuses on his controversial trial.
10 Neerja Bhanot B-class 804,187
On 5 September 1986, just two days before her 23rd birthday, this Pan Am flight attendant was shot dead by terrorists affiliated with Abu Nidal as she spearheaded an escape from the hijacked Pan Am Flight 73; an act that ultimately saved over 300 lives. She was posthumously awarded India's highest peacetime bravery award, the Ashoka Chakra. Her life and death became the subject of a Bollywood biopic this week, Neerja, starring Sonam Kapoor (pictured) in the title role.



Reader comments

2016-02-24

Wiki Loves Africa brings the continent’s fashion to the world


The following content has been republished from the Wikimedia Blog. Any views expressed in this piece are not necessarily shared by the Signpost; responses and critical commentary are invited in the comments. For more information on this partnership, see our content guidelines.



Reader comments

2016-02-24

Arbitration motion regarding CheckUser & Oversight inactivity




Reader comments

2016-02-24

This week's featured content

The Triumph of Cleopatra, an 1821 painting by William Etty, featured numerous nudes and was exhibited to great acclaim.

This Signpost "Featured content" report covers material promoted from 14 to 20 February.
Text may be adapted from the respective articles and lists; see their page histories for attribution.
Campaign poster of William McKinley for the 1896 presidential election
Route of the 2013 Tour de France

Eight featured articles were promoted this week.

  • The 70th Infantry Division (nominated by EnigmaMcmxc) of the British Army fought during the Western Desert Campaign of the Second World War. The 70th Division originated from the 7th Infantry Division, which served in the British Mandate of Palestine during the Arab Revolt. It was then transferred to Egypt on the outbreak of the Second World War and soon became the 6th Infantry Division, which took part in the Battle of Crete and the Syria–Lebanon Campaign. The 6th Division was re-created as the 70th Infantry Division, in an attempt to deceive Axis intelligence concerning the strength of the British military in the Middle East.
  • Baron Munchausen (nominated by Lemuellio) is a fictional German nobleman and soldier created by the German writer Rudolf Erich Raspe in his 1785 book Baron Munchausen's Narrative of his Marvellous Travels and Campaigns in Russia. The character is loosely based on a real baron, Hieronymus Karl Friedrich, Freiherr von Münchhausen. The fictional Baron's exploits focus on his impossible achievements as a sportsman, soldier, and traveler.
  • The Last of Us (nominated by Rhain) is an action-adventure survival horror video game developed by Naughty Dog and published by Sony Computer Entertainment. Players control Joel, a man tasked with escorting a young girl named Ellie across a post-apocalyptic United States. Development of the game began in 2009, soon after the release of Uncharted 2: Among Thieves. The team chose actors Troy Baker and Ashley Johnson to portray Joel and Ellie respectively, who provided voice and motion capture for the roles. Both assisted creative director Neil Druckmann with the development of the characters and story.
  • In 1896, William McKinley was elected President of the United States. McKinley's campaign (nominated by Wehwalt) organization was built by Mark Hanna through 1895 and 1896. Hanna raised millions for a campaign of education with trainloads of pamphlets to convince the voter that free silver would be harmful, and once that had its effect, even more were printed on protectionism. McKinley stayed at home in Canton, Ohio, running a front porch campaign and reaching millions through newspaper coverage of the speeches he gave to organized groups of people who came to see him and hear him address them. Supported by the well-to-do, urban dwellers, and prosperous farmers, McKinley won a majority of the popular vote and an easy victory in the Electoral College. McKinley's systemized approach to gaining the presidency laid the groundwork for modern campaigns, and he forged an electoral coalition that would keep the Republicans in power most of the time until 1932.
  • William Etty (nominated by Iridescent) (1787–1849) was an English artist best known for his history paintings containing nude figures. All but one of his works he exhibited at the Royal Academy in the 1820s contained at least one nude figure, and he acquired a reputation for indecency. In 1828 he was elected a Royal Academician, at the time the highest honour available to an artist. Although he was one of the most respected artists in the country he continued to study at life classes throughout his life. In the 1830s Etty began to branch out into the more lucrative but less respected field of portraiture, and later became the first English painter to paint significant still lifes. He continued to paint both male and female nudes, which caused severe criticism and condemnation from some elements of the press.
  • Michael Hordern (nominated by Cassianto) (1911–1995) was an English stage and film actor whose career spanned nearly 60 years. He is best known for his Shakespearean roles, especially that of King Lear, which he played to much acclaim on stage in Stratford-upon-Avon in 1969 and London in 1970. He then successfully assumed the role on television five years later. He often appeared in film, rising from a bit part actor in the late 1930s to a member of the main cast; by the time of his death he had appeared in nearly 140 cinema roles. His later work was predominantly in television and radio.
  • Black American Sign Language (nominated by Wugapodes) (BASL) is a dialect of American Sign Language (ASL) spoken most commonly by deaf African Americans in the United States. The divergence from ASL was influenced largely by the segregation of schools in the American South. Linguistically, BASL differs from other varieties of ASL in its phonology, syntax, and lexicon.
  • Migration of the Serbs (nominated by 23 editor) is the name given to four similar oil paintings by the artist Paja Jovanović, which depict Serbs, led by Archbishop Arsenije III, fleeing Old Serbia during the Great Serb Migration of 1690. The first version is on display at the patriarchate building of the Serbian Orthodox Church in Belgrade, the second at the Pančevo Museum, and the fourth at Princess Ljubica's Residence. Migration of the Serbs holds iconic status in Serbian popular culture, and several authors repute it to be one of Jovanović's finest achievements.

Three featured lists were promoted this week.

  • The 2013 Tour de France was the 100th edition of the race, one of cycling's Grand Tours. It started on the island of Corsica on 30 June and finished on the Champs-Élysées in Paris on 21 July. The competition featured twenty-two teams and 198 riders (nominated by BaldBoris). All of the nineteen UCI ProTeams were entitled, and obliged, to enter the race. In addition three second-tier UCI Professional Continental teams received wildcard invitations.
  • The Mexican National Lightweight Championship (nominated by MPJ-DK) is a Mexican professional wrestling singles championship created and sanctioned by Comisión de Box y Lucha Libre Mexico D.F.. Although the Commission sanctions the title, it does not promote the events in which the title is defended. The official definition of the lightweight weight class in Mexico is between 63 kg (139 lb) and 70 kg (150 lb), but the weight limits for the different classes are not always strictly enforced. As of 2016, 49 title reigns were shared between 39 wrestlers.
  • The County-Designated Highways in Michigan (nominated by Imzadi1979) comprise a 1,241.6-mile-long (1,998.2 km) system of primary county roads across the US state of Michigan. The system uses eight lettered zones which are divided by major state highways. Each county road in the system is designated with the zone letter followed by a number. Six of the zones, A–F, are in the Lower Peninsula while the Upper Peninsula is divided into the remaining two, G and H.

Four featured pictures were promoted this week.



Reader comments

2016-02-24

Tech news in brief

The following content has been republished as-is from the Tech News weekly report.



Reader comments

If articles have been updated, you may need to refresh the single-page edition.

















Wikipedia:Wikipedia Signpost/Single/2016-02-24