The Signpost

Discussion report

Discussion report for this week

The science of editing

Between them, Wikipedia:Editing scientific articles and {{ESCA}} have managed to create a fair amount of drama across Wikipedia in the last couple of days. A lengthy thread at the incidents noticeboard discussed whether User:Count Iblis was intentionally spamming Template:ESCA onto the talk pages of a number of physics articles. The page itself quickly received the attention of a number of editors, and a consensus was reached that Wikipedia:Editing scientific articles was not a guideline and was in conflict with Wikipedia:No original research. A consensus to delete Template:Esca also seems emergent at templates for discussion.

New proposals

Deletion round-up

Polls

Administrative notices

Briefly

Requests for comment

Sixteen Requests for comment have been made in the week of 2 November to 8 November:


















Wikipedia:Wikipedia Signpost/2009-11-09/Discussion_report